We are all guilty of buying into the 'one story'. Somewhere, some time in each of our lives we have all said something like this: 'All politicians are liars'; 'No one who has been to Alaska can say it's not cold'; 'People who eat meat are unhealthy'. These are all examples of the 'one story', which are not only generalist and ineffective, but they are also untrue.
One Stories tend to lower the common denominator so that we can save ourselves the trouble of doing a lot of thinking about people and the things we do and have, which means we can sit and luxuriate in our own comfort zones. One Stories are breeding grounds for racism, sexism, and a whole lot of other isms which are all too easy to slip into.
Sure, we like to be connected to other people, so having some common bonds is good, but these need to be actively created rather than artificially constructed. Too much of the One Story and we no longer recognise and appreciate difference, and people are robbed of their dignity in the process.
Quite different to One Stories are Practised Stories - 'practised' does not mean that the telling is rehearsed, but that the stories are lived ones, by real people living real lives. Not only are the messages are rich and meaningful; they take us to a higher level of understanding of the complexity and richness of humanity in all its permutations. Practised stories are often known as applied stories - by this we mean that the stories that are experienced and reflected on are used to create positive transformational change.
Imagine a world that is rich with stories, a world that brings new delights each day. Imagine if the newspapers and current affairs programs were full of Practiced Stories rather than One Stories - Tiger Woods would not be apologising on screen for yet another extra-marital blunder but might actually say something interesting that he has learned about himself and the world. Then rather than hearing all the socially-contrived excuses, we might see how his experience has allowed Tiger and the rest of the world an opportunity to become positively transformed by his experience.
This does not mean to indicate that only celebrities are worthy of Practised Stories. In fact, the best Practised Stories are those about ordinary but distinguishably different people - in fact, the living and telling makes them a little less ordinary, a lot less stereotypical, and a little more distinguishably different. Practised Stories are empowering, humanising, and transformational - they show we exist, and how we exist.
Practised Stories reveal greater truths in the experiences themselves and are uncovered further in the telling. Obviously, this places a huge responsibility on the story practitioner, and this has more to do with intent and less to do with expertise.
If you want to find out more about being a Story Practitioner, go to the Story Practitioner's Space page.
Showing posts with label change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label change. Show all posts
Sunday, March 28, 2010
Saturday, March 13, 2010
Punctuation Points in Transformative Stories
When you read a book, go to a live play, the opera, or ballet, or watch a movie, there will almost always be bits that make you sit up and take notice, and that usually cause an emotional reaction of some kind. (Those who have attended Samuel Beckett's plays such as End Game, Waiting for Godot, in which the only reaction is boredom, more boredom, and even more boredom, will realise there are exceptions to this rule).
When you are in conversation with someone and they are telling you a story, it also always more interesting when you find yourself actively involved, wanting to know more - you will start asking questions, or providing the right noises to encourage the person to continue.
I like to call these 'punctuation points'. Usually, we won't remember the whole story but we will remember the things that made us exclaim, question, think more about something. These are usually aligned to key moments in the protagonist's journey.
For example, the slow build up of caring for a neighbour's child one day, full of routine activities like baking a cake, cutting shapes out of paper, watching Play School is not likely to engage the listener, unless of course there is a complication - 'He didn't realise the beaters were moving so fast and he jammed his fingers between them, there was blood everywhere and I panicked. What should I do?' (I bet you want to know what happened next). Or, for a less gory story, 'She got up and danced the whole Dying Swan scene, from start to finish, I couldn't believe how talented she was, you have to see it!
As you can see, these bits of excitement usually finish with some kind of punctuation - a question mark, and exclamation mark etc. These punctuation points usually preface some kind of transformation - the little boy who jammed his fingers was taken to hospital, plastic surgery was performed but he never regained full use of his fingers, the little girl's parents were astonished to hear she could dance so well, she had never done this at home - they enrolled her in ballet school and she won a dance scholarship at the age of 15.
Extending this, we can see how, in a transformational/applied story, it is important to identify the punctuation points that give life and meaning to the story, and to a person's life journey.
When you are in conversation with someone and they are telling you a story, it also always more interesting when you find yourself actively involved, wanting to know more - you will start asking questions, or providing the right noises to encourage the person to continue.
I like to call these 'punctuation points'. Usually, we won't remember the whole story but we will remember the things that made us exclaim, question, think more about something. These are usually aligned to key moments in the protagonist's journey.
For example, the slow build up of caring for a neighbour's child one day, full of routine activities like baking a cake, cutting shapes out of paper, watching Play School is not likely to engage the listener, unless of course there is a complication - 'He didn't realise the beaters were moving so fast and he jammed his fingers between them, there was blood everywhere and I panicked. What should I do?' (I bet you want to know what happened next). Or, for a less gory story, 'She got up and danced the whole Dying Swan scene, from start to finish, I couldn't believe how talented she was, you have to see it!
As you can see, these bits of excitement usually finish with some kind of punctuation - a question mark, and exclamation mark etc. These punctuation points usually preface some kind of transformation - the little boy who jammed his fingers was taken to hospital, plastic surgery was performed but he never regained full use of his fingers, the little girl's parents were astonished to hear she could dance so well, she had never done this at home - they enrolled her in ballet school and she won a dance scholarship at the age of 15.
Extending this, we can see how, in a transformational/applied story, it is important to identify the punctuation points that give life and meaning to the story, and to a person's life journey.
Thursday, March 4, 2010
Transformation - a new story archetype?
This site and Transformative Narrative Project are all about change, of course! So where does this fit into the story archetypes that Booker talked about.
1. Tragedy - the hero with a fatal flaw has a tragic ending
2. Comedy - a happy and/or romantic ending
3. Overcoming the monster - the good guy (or, as in the case of Lara Croft, girl) wins the day
4. Voyage and return - the protagonist sets out on a journey and faces many demons, leading to personal development, then returns and talks about it
5. Quest - the hero sets out to find an object or person of importance
6. Rags to riches (or riches to rags to riches)
7. Rebirth - the hero loses something important, and along with this the reason for living, then finds a new reason to live and is 'reborn'
In my last blog post I made the distinction between pure comedy and romance, creating an 8th category.
Also in the last post I asked people to reflect on what kind of story would inform their own narrative in an applied story sense. If you have tried this out, using a pivotal moment in your life, maybe you will have decided that none of these categories is sufficiently adequate on its own. As they say, truth is stranger than fiction - and real life stories are complex and often difficult to unravel. There is an art involved, and if the story is being told by someone other than the 'main protagonist', there is a great responsibility to honour that person's truth (which may also shift and change in the course of the relating and retelling).
I am making a bold assumption that Booker's story archetypes are of little use to the Transformative Narrative Project, except to highlight the differences between the traditional storytelling theory and methodology and those of applied storytelling.
For this we need a whole new category: transformation - my working definition of this being 'a story that follows a process of change that has an important impact on the hero's (or heroine's) life'. The story contains a journey, or a part of a journey, that the particular person sees as pivotal in their life, and which has changed/transformed them in some way. There could be romance or comedy, even tragedy involved, but the real life protagonist in transformational story telling actually goes through a fundamental change in the way he or she feels, believes, and behaves.
Which life events can be seen as transformative? The list is endless, of course. Obviously it is not the event itself that is important, but the impact it has on us. For some of us, a simple word or two by a trusted mentor is enough to change the course of our lives, for others, winning gold in a sports event may be meaningless. It all depends on our own raison d'etre, our personal goals, motivations, values. In this way, we can see that applied storytelling is a very democratic process - everyone has at least one story to tell.
1. Tragedy - the hero with a fatal flaw has a tragic ending
2. Comedy - a happy and/or romantic ending
3. Overcoming the monster - the good guy (or, as in the case of Lara Croft, girl) wins the day
4. Voyage and return - the protagonist sets out on a journey and faces many demons, leading to personal development, then returns and talks about it
5. Quest - the hero sets out to find an object or person of importance
6. Rags to riches (or riches to rags to riches)
7. Rebirth - the hero loses something important, and along with this the reason for living, then finds a new reason to live and is 'reborn'
In my last blog post I made the distinction between pure comedy and romance, creating an 8th category.
Also in the last post I asked people to reflect on what kind of story would inform their own narrative in an applied story sense. If you have tried this out, using a pivotal moment in your life, maybe you will have decided that none of these categories is sufficiently adequate on its own. As they say, truth is stranger than fiction - and real life stories are complex and often difficult to unravel. There is an art involved, and if the story is being told by someone other than the 'main protagonist', there is a great responsibility to honour that person's truth (which may also shift and change in the course of the relating and retelling).
I am making a bold assumption that Booker's story archetypes are of little use to the Transformative Narrative Project, except to highlight the differences between the traditional storytelling theory and methodology and those of applied storytelling.
For this we need a whole new category: transformation - my working definition of this being 'a story that follows a process of change that has an important impact on the hero's (or heroine's) life'. The story contains a journey, or a part of a journey, that the particular person sees as pivotal in their life, and which has changed/transformed them in some way. There could be romance or comedy, even tragedy involved, but the real life protagonist in transformational story telling actually goes through a fundamental change in the way he or she feels, believes, and behaves.
Which life events can be seen as transformative? The list is endless, of course. Obviously it is not the event itself that is important, but the impact it has on us. For some of us, a simple word or two by a trusted mentor is enough to change the course of our lives, for others, winning gold in a sports event may be meaningless. It all depends on our own raison d'etre, our personal goals, motivations, values. In this way, we can see that applied storytelling is a very democratic process - everyone has at least one story to tell.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)